How Can a Leader Recognize Good Employee Conflict?
conflict conflict management continuous improvement employees engagement good conflict manager supervisorThe Conflict Gem
You may ask yourself, how can two employees engage in good conflict? Well, the truth is, is that some employee conflict is good conflict and it’s important for leaders know how to recognize the difference between good conflict and unproductive conflict.
When employees engage in unproductive conflict, then unfortunately their supervisor needs to intervene and help them come to a resolution and if the conflict continues then more formal corrective action steps are required. However, the good type of conflict is a continuous improvement gem. The supervisor just needs to be able to recognize the difference causes of conflict and respond accordingly.
So what are the aspects of good conflict? Well first good conflict will always be about a work-related issue. If employees are in conflict about a process issue, or the best way to accomplish their work or about a tool that is lacking or a disorganized situation, well this is all good conflict. You see both employees care about the success of their work. The conflict that arose is because both employees are striving to meet their objectives, but this shared issue is in their way and preventing success. Thus, the conflict.
In the middle of this conflict, lies a gem! This is an opportunity for a supervisor to step in and engage both employees in the solution. For example, can they work together to create a documented standard work instruction? Can they purchase an additional tool that will make them more efficient? Or can they agree on a better project structure to improve a timeline? You see, solving the conflict, results in an improvement.
At the core of every good conflict are good motives and when two people with good motives work together to solve problems, the result is called continuous improvement. A supervisor just needs to recognize the situation and facilitate the conversation in order to find the improvement gem. But, make no mistake about it, even good conflict can cause some emotional strife because conscientious employees have a passion for success and obstacles can be frustrating.
Now how do we recognize unproductive conflict. Well, here are some red flags. First, the conflict may not be work-related. If it’s not work-related, it’s not good conflict. Second, if the conflict is about something overly nit-picky or extremely minor, then that is a red flag that it is more of a personal conflict than a work-related conflict. The same goes for constant bickering. Whenever the same two people are in constant, conflict, well that is definitely unproductive conflict. Lastly, unprofessional language and actions are clearly considered unproductive, and it needs to be formally addressed.
In summary, when evaluating whether you are dealing with good conflict or unproductive conflict, you cannot determine it based on the level of emotion because sometimes good conflict carries emotion. Instead look at motive. Do both employees have the right motives? Are they striving to achieve results? Are the employees in conflict because of a work-related issue? If so, help them to find the gem of continuous improvement within the conflict. Trust me, the gem is there.
However, if employees are in conflict about a non work-related issue or they are being overly nitpicky or they are constantly bickering or they are saying or doing unprofessional things, then that is unproductive conflict and needs to be formally addressed.
Are you interested in developing the leadership expertise in yourself or your employees? Check out Tools for the Trenches (T4T). T4T is leadership training designed specifically for manufacturing supervisors.
Stay connected with news and updates!
If you want some weekly T4T wisdom coming straight to your inbox for your reading pleasure - look no further! Join our mailing list to receive the latest blogs and updates.
Don't worry, your information will not be shared.
We hate SPAM. We will never sell your information, for any reason.
CATEGORIES
All Categories 5 whys 5s 5s standardize 5s sustain 6m's ability accomplishment accomplishments accountability accuracy action action plans actions ada addiction addiction help admiration adverserial aerospace affordable agenda agriculture ai alcohol alcoholism amazon american disabilities act anderson-darling appreciation approachability approval art artificial intelligence artisan assembly assembly line assessment assignments attention to details attribute gage r&r auto industry auto manufacturing auto production automobile manufacturing average avoidance best practices big bend black belt boss boulder city bourbon trail breakdown budget business business case business model business proposals candidate experience candidates capability capability study cape fear capital career cargo cash flow caterpillar cell design cememt central limit theorem central tendancy ceo certification certification training challenges change change management changeover reduction chaos chemical child labor ci cnc cnc programming cogs communication communitiy company compassion compitition concrete conducting interviews conflict conflict management consistency constraints construction consumption continuous improvement conversion loss corrective action correlation analysis cost savings costs course cp cp and cpk cpk cross-functional cross-training cross-training matrix crude culture current state current state map customer customer satisfaction customer service customer value customers cv daily goals dallas dam dashboard data data analytics data collection data transformation debt-free decision maker defects deliverables demand department design design loss design of experiment design review design reviews develop development dfm diet difficulties direct labor discussion discussions diversity document document control documentation doe drilling driving results drug use duluth dumping e learn e-learning eap ebit education effective effectiveness effectivity effects of change efficiency effort email empathy empirical rule employee employee assistance program employee development employee engagement employee recgonition employees encourage encouragement enforcement engagement engineer engineering equipment error proof excellence exercise expectations expertise experts facilitate facilitator factories factory family life farming feedback financial financials fishing fixed mindset flexibility flexible follow-up foolproof ford forecast fossil fuels fred jones freightliners friendships frontline leaders fun gage r&r gages gasoline gemba general motors goal alignment goals gold gold rush goldrush good conflict graphs great lakes great teams gross margins gross profits growth growth mindset guidance habits health healthy heavy equipment henry ford heritage hiring histogram history hoover dam housekeeping how to be a great teammate how to thrill customer human relations human resources hydro-electric hydro-electric power hypothesis testing ice breaker illinios river valley illinois illinois river immersion importing improve improvement industiral industrial industrial engineering industrial heritage industrial heritgage industrial history industry industry 4.0 inequity injury prevention innovation inspection instructions integrity interactive learning internal promotion interview questions interview skills interview tips interviewing inventory inventory shrinkage investment iowa irresponsible jack daniels distillery tour job diversity job shop job shops jobs john deere kaizen kanban kappa kentucky knowledge lead leader leaders leadership leadership development leadership skills leading lean lean champion lean culture lean implementation lean journey lean kickoff lean launch lean manufacturing lean pilot project lean six sigma lean strategy lean tools lean vision learn learning leisure letter of commendation lifestyle logging logistics louisiana low prices lumber machine machine guarding machine speed machines maintenance making a pitch management management by walking around manager managers managing managing conflict managing the floor manpower manufactuing manufacturing manufacturing leaders manufacturing leadership manufacturing plants manufacturing results manufacturing supervisor manufacturing supervisor leadership manufacturing traning manufacturing variance mardi gras marfa material mbwa mean measurement meditation meeting meetings mental health mental tension mentee mentor mentoring mentorship metallurgy methods metrics midland milestones milk run mindset mining mininig minnesota mississippi river model-t morale mother nature motivation muda multivariant analysis museum national park nature new hires new orleans new products night shift nimble business normal distribution normality test north carolina objectives office oil ojt okc oklahoma on line courses on time delivery on-site factories on-time delivery onboarding one-on-one online open-door operational excellence operator operators opex ore organization otd output overhead ownership p&l p-value packaging packaging material partner partnering partnership partnerships pdca pdca cycle peers peoria performance performance management performance patterns performance review performance reviews perimian basis personal accountability personal growth personal grwoth personality petroleum pharmaceuticals pikes place pitch plan planner planning plant plant costs plastics point of use poka yoke poka-yoke policy port portland cement positive feedback positive interactions pou power plant pp ppk praise predictive maintenance presentation presentation anxiety presentations preventative maintenance prices prime costs principles printing private label problem solving problem statement problems procedure procedures process process capability process center process controls process engineer process management process variation product development product testing production production flow production supervisor productive conflict productivity products professionalism profit profits profressional development progress project project assumptions project charter project justification project management project objectives project timing projections projects promoted props provide qms qualifies quality quality control quality management system quality tool quality training quick changeover r&d range rapid changeover recognition recognize recruiting recycling red tag referals refinery relationship reliability reputation resolving conflict resources respect responsibility responsible restore results resume resume screening resumes revenue rewards rigs risk management roi rolling-5 rolling-5 action plans root cause roots routine safety safety incentives sales sales tips sales volume salesperson sampling science scope scrap screening screening applicants sculptures seattle self-promotion selling service set in order set up times set-in-order set-up reduction shadow board shadowing share shareholder shine shipbuilding shipping shopfloor single minute of exchange of die single-piece six-sigma skill development skills sleep slideshow smart goals sme smed social life solutions sort specifications specs speed to market staffing staffing model standard cost standard deviation standardize starved rock state-of-the-art statistics stats staycation steamship steel steel fabrication steel industry strategy stress stress management strong leader structure subject matter expert success sugar mill supervision supervisor supervisor development supervisor leadership supervisors supervsior supplier supplier management supply chain support support resources sustain systems t-test tactical takt tariffs teach teaching team team work team-based teammate teams teamwork technical tennesse whiskey tennessee texas the great depression the hoover dam the normal distribution curve timber time management time-series tools tourism toyota production system tpm tps training training methods travel troubleshooting trust turn around two sample t-test types of change understanding us manufacturing vacation validation value value stream value stream map value-driven values variance variances variation velocity vendor managed inventory video violations visual factory vmi voc volunteering vsm war on waste washington waste waste reduction waterway wellbeing wilmington nc work instructions work rules workforce workplace workplace conflict